Can a foreign student use two different Passports to get two different State ID Cards?

I have heard of this rumor before, I want to know that can a foreign student use two different passports from same country with different Date of Birth and Name to get two different State ID cards. I know this is illegal, but is it possible?

Can a foreign student use two different Passports to get two different State ID Cards?
Sure, go right ahead. But , no whining when immigration cancels your student visa nd deports you.
Reply:yes its possible as long as you have the two passports and the birth certificate you can do it but be careful
Reply:I guess I'm just not sure where they'd get two different passports. I'm not aware of any country on this planet that would allow that. It's technically possible to have passports from two different countries, if you have dual citizenship, but still, your name and dob would match on both, so one or the other would have to be faked. That would be much more difficult than just buying a fake state ID off the street.

my fish